1880s 1890s 1900s 1910s 1920s 1930s 1940s 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s 1990s 2000s 2010s 2020s
1890/91
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 31 Jan 1891 | Bootle Wanderers | W | 7-0 | A | QF | Robert Jones (2), Patrick Gordon, James McMillan, Unknown |
| 21 Feb 1891 | Prescot | W | 8-1 | H | SF | James McMillan (3), Alec Brady (2), Alex Latta, Unknown |
| 27 Apr 1891 | Bootle (1879) | W | 4-1 | A | F | Edgar Chadwick (2), Harry Hammond (2) 🏆 |
1891/92
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 Apr 1892 | Bootle (1879) | W | 2-1 | H | SF | Fred Geary, Unknown (80 mins long) |
| 26 Apr 1892 | Southport | W | 2-1 | N | F | James McMillan (2) (played at Hawthorne Road) 🏆 |
1892/93
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Mar 1893 | Aigburth Vale | W | 8-0 | A | QF | Joey Murray, George Smith, Unknown |
| 11 Apr 1893 | Aintree Church | W | 7-1 | N | SF | Abe Hartley (3), Patrick Gordon (2), Jack Elliott, Robert Jones (played at Hawthorne Road) |
| 22 Apr 1893 | Liverpool | L | 0-1 | N | F | (played at Hawthorne Road) |
1893/94
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Apr 1894 | Southport | W | 4-1 | H | QF | Abe Hartley (2 – 1 pen), James McMillan, Joey Murray |
| 17 Apr 1894 | Chester | W | 5-1 | N | SF | Unknown (played at Chester Street, Birkenhead) |
| 30 Apr 1894 | Liverpool | W | 3-0 | N | F | David Storrier, own goal, Abe Hartley (played at Police Athletic Ground, Fairfield) 🏆 |
1894/95
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9 Mar 1895 | Southport | D | 1-1 | A | SF | Joey Murray |
| 28 Mar 1895 | Southport | W | 2-0 | H | SFr | B. Clarke, James McMillan |
| 29 Apr 1895 | Liverpool | W | 3-0 | H | F | James McMillan, David Storrier, John Hill 🏆 |
1895/96
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Feb 1896 | Southport | W | 5-1 | H | SF | Unknown |
| 28 Mar 1896 | Chester | W | 4-0 | H | F | Bill Williams (2), Alf Schofield, Unknown 🏆 |
1896/97
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 29 Apr 1897 | Rock Ferry | L | 1-2 | H | F | Bill Williams |
1897/98
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 Feb 1898 | White Star | W | 4-1 | H | SF | John Barlow (2), Ted Turner, Alf Schofield |
| 23 Apr 1898 | New Brighton Tower | W | 3-0 | H | F | Ellis Gee, Dickie Boyle, Jack Kirwan 🏆 |
1898/99
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18 Mar 1899 | Tranmere | W | 2-1 | H | SF | Thomas Crompton, Laurie Bell |
| 27 Apr 1899 | New Brighton Tower | W | 8-1 | H | F | Wilfred Oldham (4), Jack Bell (2 – 1 pen), Ellis Gee 🏆 |
1899/1900
| Date | Opponents | FT | V | Rd | Scorers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 21 Apr 1900 | New Brighton Tower | D | 0-0 | H | F | |
| 27 Apr 1900 | New Brighton Tower | W | 2-0 | A | Fr | Billy Dawson, Ellis Gee 🏆 |