| Everton Reserves | 3 |
John R. Cameron 25' Davie McDonald 55' 1 unknown scorer | |
| Chester | 1 |
Worgan 30' | |
HT: 1-1
Saturday 12 September 1896
Line-Up
Italics indicate may have played but not yet confirmed.
- Bob Menham
- Hugh Gordon
- George Molyneux
- William Nash
- George Meiklejohn
- John Tait Robertson
- Bill Williams
- William Campbell
- John R. Cameron
- Davie McDonald
- Alf Schofield