| Denton | 0 |
| Everton Reserves | 7 |
7 unknown scorers | |
HT: 0-?
Saturday 26 December 1891
Line-Up
Italics indicate may have played but not yet confirmed.
- David Jardine
- Albert Chadwick
- James Collins
- Dan Kirkwood
- Robert Jones
- Alex Lochhead
- Patrick Gordon
- Joey Murray
- Archie Pinnell
- James McMillan
- Jack Elliott