| Everton Reserves | 2 |
Eddie Thomas 14' Noel Dwyer 84' (og) | |
| Wolverhampton Wanderers Reserves | 3 |
Harry Hooper 78' (p) Des Horne 82' Barry Stobart 87' | |
HT: 1-0
Monday 9 September 1957
Line-Up
Italics indicate may have played but not yet confirmed.
- Jimmy O'Neill
- Allan Sanders
- Fred Leeder
- Johnny King
- Brian Labone
- Peter Farrell
- Jackie Keeley
- Jimmy Gauld
- George Kirby
- Eddie Thomas
- Graham Williams