| Everton Reserves | 5 |
Dave Hickson 10', 12', 67' Eddie Thomas 42' (p) Alec Ashworth 65' | |
| Aston Villa Reserves | 3 |
Brian Handley 1' Billy Myerscough 23' Roly Morris 69' | |
HT: 3-2
Saturday 21 December 1957
Line-Up
- Jimmy O'Neill
- Ken Birch
- Fred Leeder
- Johnny King
- Brian Labone
- Mick Meagan
- Alec Ashworth
- Eddie Thomas
- Dave Hickson
- Jackie Keeley
- Bennett Steele