| Everton Reserves | 0 |
| Barnsley Reserves | 2 |
Billy Houghton ??' Johnny Edgar ??' | |
HT: 0-0
Saturday 18 January 1958
Line-Up
- Jimmy O'Neill
- Bryan Griffiths
- Fred Leeder
- Johnny King
- Brian Labone
- Terry Gannon
- Dave Todd
- Wally Fielding
- Jimmy Blain
- William Haughey
- Bennett Steele