| Sheffield United Reserves | 1 |
Jimmy Hagan 38' | |
| Everton Reserves | 1 |
Tommy Hoyland 32' (og) | |
HT: 1-1
Saturday 1 February 1958
Line-Up
- Jimmy O'Neill
- Fred Leeder
- Jimmy Tansey
- Johnny King
- Brian Labone
- Ken Rea
- Dave Todd
- Frank McKay
- Alec Ashworth
- Wally Fielding
- Bennett Steele