| Everton Reserves | 1 |
Brian Godfrey 18' | |
| Newcastle United Reserves | 0 |
HT: 1-0
Monday 21 April 1958
Line-Up
Italics indicate may have played but not yet confirmed.
- Albert Dunlop
- Don Donovan
- Ian Hillsdon
- Arthur Peat
- Stan Billington
- John Bramwell
- Dave Todd
- Derek Temple
- Dave Hickson
- Frank McKay
- Brian Godfrey