| Newcastle United Reserves | 4 |
Bill Curry 23', 85' Harry Taylor 52' Ken Hale 86' | |
| Everton Reserves | 2 |
George Kirby 56' Frank Wignall 83' | |
HT: 1-0
Saturday 13 December 1958
Line-Up
- Jimmy O'Neill
- Stan Billington
- Jimmy Tansey
- Ken Rea
- Brian Labone
- Alec Ashworth
- Wally Fielding
- Frank Wignall
- Peter Harburn
- George Kirby
- Eddie O'Hara