| Everton Reserves | 2 |
Jimmy Blain 4' Frank Wignall 71' | |
| Chesterfield Reserves | 0 |
HT: 1-0
Friday 27 March 1959
Line-Up
Italics indicate may have played but not yet confirmed.
- Jimmy O'Neill
- John Parkes
- Jimmy Tansey
- Johnny Clayton
- Brian Labone
- Arthur Peat
- Jimmy Blain
- Frank Wignall
- Jackie Hood
- Frank McKay
- Brian Godfrey