| Everton Reserves | 1 |
Eddie Thomas 87' | |
| Aston Villa Reserves | 1 |
Mike Kenning 3' | |
HT: 0-1
Saturday 12 September 1959
Line-Up
- Jimmy O'Neill
- Alan Bentham
- John Bramwell
- Ken Rea
- Stan Billington
- Mick Meagan
- Arthur Peat
- Alan Tyrer
- Alec Ashworth
- Eddie Thomas
- Jimmy Blain