| Everton Reserves | 1 |
Frank Wignall 27' | |
| Sheffield Wednesday Reserves | 2 |
Billy Griffin 46', 67' | |
HT: 1-0
Saturday 16 January 1960
Line-Up
- Albert Dunlop
- Jimmy Tansey
- John Bramwell
- Ken Rea
- Stan Billington
- Brian Harris
- Bobby Laverick
- Jimmy Harris
- Frank Wignall
- Jimmy Shepherd
- Eddie O'Hara