| Everton Reserves | 2 |
Alan Shackleton 24' Derek Temple 65' | |
| Newcastle United Reserves | 2 |
Harry Taylor 43' Johnny McGuigan 66' | |
HT: 1-1
Saturday 19 March 1960
Line-Up
- Jimmy O'Neill
- Jimmy Tansey
- Colin Green
- Brian Harris
- Stan Billington
- George Sharples
- Derek Temple
- Frank Wignall
- Alan Shackleton
- Jimmy Shepherd
- Bobby Laverick