| Everton Reserves | 3 |
Joe Royle 26' Gerry Humphreys 28' Stuart Shaw 44' | |
| Bury Reserves | 1 |
Bobby Owen 9' | |
HT: 3-1
Saturday 11 December 1965
Line-Up
- Gordon West
- Sandy Brown
- Frank D'Arcy
- Derek Smith
- Roger Kenyon
- Dennis Stevens
- Stuart Shaw
- Jimmy Gabriel
- Joe Royle
- Gerry Humphreys
- Johnny Morrissey