| Everton Reserves | 2 |
Danny Cadamarteri 2' Jamie Milligan 20' | |
| Sunderland Reserves | 5 |
Michael Bridges 5', 50' Danny Dichio 44' John Mullin 75' Jody Craddock 85' | |
HT: 2-2
Tuesday 6 April 1999
1998/99 Central League Division 1
Line-Up
- Steve Simonsen
- Carl Regan
- Adam Eaton
- Peter Clarke
- John O'Kane
- Mitch Ward
- Peter Degn
- John Oster
- Danny Cadamarteri
- Phil Jevons
- Jamie Milligan