| Everton Reserves | 4 |
Leon Osman 2' Phil Jevons 31', 40' Danny Cadamarteri 59' | |
| Sheffield Wednesday Reserves | 2 |
Richard Cresswell 1' Richard Dunne 81' (og) | |
HT: 3-1
Tuesday 7 March 2000
1999/2000 Premier Reserve League North
Line-Up
- Paul Gerrard
- Richard Dunne
- Dave Watson
- Gary Dempsey
- Adam Farley
- Jamie Milligan
- Scot Gemmill
- Danny Cadamarteri
- Leon Osman
- Phil Jevons
- Don Hutchison