| Everton Reserves | 4 |
Jack Elliott 70' Archie Pinnell 80' 2 unknown scorers | |
| Buxton | 0 |
HT: 0-0
Saturday 7 October 1893
Line-Up
- Charlie Parry
- Albert Chadwick
- Smart Arridge
- Jack Walker
- Robert Jones
- Barney Coyle
- Harry Reay
- Archie Pinnell
- Abe Hartley
- James McMillan
- Jack Elliott