| Everton Reserves | 4 |
Jimmy Gourlay 13', 35' Harry Mountford ??' (p) Charles Pratt ??' | |
| Oldham Athletic Reserves | 1 |
Doughty 8' | |
HT: 3-1
Monday 13 September 1909
1909/10 Lancashire Combination Division 1
Line-Up
- Clarence Berry
- William Stevenson
- John Bardsley
- Dan Rafferty
- Charles Pratt
- Bob Clifford
- William Michael
- Billy Lacey
- Jimmy Gourlay
- Robert Anderson
- Harry Mountford