| Everton Reserves | 0 |
| Lincoln City | 1 |
Sandy McCubbin ??' | |
HT: 0-1
Monday 1 January 1912
Line-Up
- Clarence Berry
- Bob Balmer
- James Meunier
- Jack Allan
- Louis Weller
- Alan Grenyer
- Sam Chedgzoy
- Ernie Pinkney
- Jimmy Gourlay
- Andy Burton
- Billy Lacey
| Everton Reserves | 0 |
| Lincoln City | 1 |
Sandy McCubbin ??' | |
HT: 0-1
Monday 1 January 1912