| Everton Reserves | 6 |
John Hill ??' 5 unknown scorers | |
| Leek | 0 |
HT: 1-0
Saturday 14 September 1895
Line-Up
- Arthur Hiles(trial)
- Hector McDonald
- David Storrier
- W. Jones(trial)
- George Meiklejohn
- Jack Elliott
- Harry Reay
- Joey Murray
- Harry Mainman
- John Hill
- Alf Schofield(trial)