| Buxton | 0 |
| Everton Reserves | 6 |
Joey Murray 23' Bill Williams 33', 39' Jack Elliott 41' Hugh Goldie 70' 1 unknown scorer | |
HT: 0-4
Friday 3 April 1896
Line-Up
- Henry Briggs
- Billy Balmer
- George Molyneux
- Bob Kelso
- George Meiklejohn
- Hugh Goldie
- Bill Williams
- Joey Murray
- Jim Chadwick
- Davie McDonald
- Jack Elliott