Everton players who have scored on their competitive debut for the club. (Excludes returning debuts.)
Click on the date of the match for details.
See also:
- Goalscoring Debutants (Full Debut)
- Goalscoring Debutants (League Debut)
- Goalscoring Debutants (Premier League)
- Goalscoring Debutants (Home Debut)
| Player | Season | Date | Opponents | Competition | Gls |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tommy Costley | 1888/89 | 20 Oct 1888 | Derby County | Football League | 2 |
| William Brown | 1888/89 | 3 Nov 1888 | Bolton Wanderers | Football League | 1 |
| Shamrock Coyne | 1888/89 | 24 Nov 1888 | Burnley | Football League | 1 |
| Charlie Parry | 1889/90 | 7 Sep 1889 | Blackburn Rovers | Football League | 1 |
| Fred Geary | 1889/90 | 7 Sep 1889 | Blackburn Rovers | Football League | 2 |
| William Marr Orr | 1889/90 | 5 Oct 1889 | Derby County | Football League | 1 |
| Alec Brady | 1889/90 | 2 Nov 1889 | Stoke | Football League | 2 |
| Walter Campbell | 1890/91 | 6 Sep 1890 | West Bromwich Albion | Football League | 1 |
| Abe Hartley | 1892/93 | 18 Mar 1893 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | First Division | 1 |
| Jack Southworth | 1893/94 | 9 Sep 1893 | Derby County | First Division | 1 |
| Jack Walker | 1893/94 | 16 Sep 1893 | Aston Villa | First Division | 1 |
| Harry Reay | 1893/94 | 16 Apr 1894 | Bolton Wanderers | First Division | 1 |
| Tom McInnes | 1894/95 | 1 Sep 1894 | The Wednesday | First Division | 1 |
| Bill Williams | 1894/95 | 7 Jan 1895 | Stoke | First Division | 1 |
| Albert Flewitt | 1895/96 | 7 Sep 1895 | Nottingham Forest | First Division | 1 |
| John Cameron | 1895/96 | 5 Oct 1895 | Sheffield United | First Division | 1 |
| Jack Taylor | 1896/97 | 5 Sep 1896 | The Wednesday | First Division | 1 |
| Laurie Bell | 1897/98 | 4 Sep 1897 | Bolton Wanderers | First Division | 2 |
| John Divers | 1897/98 | 11 Sep 1897 | Derby County | First Division | 1 |
| Harry Clark | 1898/99 | 1 Sep 1898 | Blackburn Rovers | First Division | 1 |
| John Proudfoot | 1898/99 | 1 Sep 1898 | Blackburn Rovers | First Division | 1 |
| Wilfred Oldham | 1898/99 | 8 Oct 1898 | Bolton Wanderers | First Division | 1 |
| Joe Turner | 1899/1900 | 28 Apr 1900 | Manchester City | First Division | 2 |
| Harold Hardman | 1903/04 | 1 Sep 1903 | Blackburn Rovers | First Division | 1 |
| Frank Oliver | 1905/06 | 14 Oct 1905 | Notts County | First Division | 3 |
| Thomas "Prescot" Jones | 1905/06 | 14 Apr 1906 | Derby County | First Division | 1 |
| Harry Mountford | 1907/08 | 2 Nov 1907 | Nottingham Forest | First Division | 1 |
| George Barlow | 1908/09 | 19 Sep 1908 | Middlesbrough | First Division | 1 |
| Bob Turner | 1908/09 | 9 Apr 1909 | Liverpool | First Division | 1 |
| Jimmy Gourlay | 1909/10 | 19 Mar 1910 | Chelsea | First Division | 1 |
| Louis Weller | 1909/10 | 11 Apr 1910 | Blackburn Rovers | First Division | 1 |
| Teddy Magner | 1910/11 | 7 Jan 1911 | Preston North End | First Division | 1 |
| Andy Burton | 1911/12 | 2 Sep 1911 | Tottenham Hotspur | First Division | 1 |
| Tommy Browell | 1911/12 | 6 Jan 1912 | Manchester United | First Division | 2 |
| Sammy Simms | 1912/13 | 26 Dec 1912 | Blackburn Rovers | First Division | 1 |
| James Brannick | 1912/13 | 26 Dec 1912 | Blackburn Rovers | First Division | 1 |
| Tom Page | 1913/14 | 4 Oct 1913 | Middlesbrough | First Division | 1 |
| Lance Johnston | 1913/14 | 11 Oct 1913 | Sheffield United | First Division | 1 |
| Tommy Nuttall | 1913/14 | 18 Oct 1913 | Derby County | First Division | 2 |
| Bobby Parker | 1913/14 | 6 Dec 1913 | The Wednesday | First Division | 1 |
| Joe Clennell | 1913/14 | 24 Jan 1914 | Aston Villa | First Division | 1 |
| Billy Kirsopp | 1914/15 | 1 Jan 1915 | Tottenham Hotspur | First Division | 1 |
| Tommy Mayson | 1919/20 | 30 Aug 1919 | Chelsea | First Division | 1 |
| Bert Rigsby | 1919/20 | 3 Sep 1919 | Bradford Park Avenue | First Division | 1 |
| Joe Kearslake | 1919/20 | 28 Feb 1920 | Oldham Athletic | First Division | 1 |
| John Blair | 1919/20 | 2 Apr 1920 | Derby County | First Division | 2 |
| Stan Davies | 1920/21 | 5 Feb 1921 | Manchester City | First Division | 1 |
| Wilf Chadwick | 1921/22 | 4 Mar 1922 | Bradford City | First Division | 2 |
| Jack Cock | 1922/23 | 20 Jan 1923 | Stoke | First Division | 1 |
| David "DJ" Murray | 1925/26 | 5 Sep 1925 | Cardiff City | First Division | 1 |
| Dick Forshaw | 1926/27 | 5 Mar 1927 | Newcastle United | First Division | 1 |
| Tony Weldon | 1926/27 | 12 Mar 1927 | Leeds United | First Division | 1 |
| Tommy White | 1927/28 | 22 Oct 1927 | West Ham United | First Division | 2 |
| Charlie Gee | 1930/31 | 1 Jan 1931 | Bury | Second Division | 1 |
| Albert Geldard | 1932/33 | 19 Nov 1932 | Middlesbrough | First Division | 1 |
| Nat Cunliffe | 1932/33 | 25 Mar 1933 | Aston Villa | First Division | 1 |
| Charlie Leyfield | 1934/35 | 29 Aug 1934 | Leicester City | First Division | 1 |
| Billy Hartill | 1935/36 | 11 Sep 1935 | Portsmouth | First Division | 1 |
| Stan Bentham | 1935/36 | 23 Nov 1935 | Grimsby Town | First Division | 2 |
| Bunny Bell | 1935/36 | 18 Apr 1936 | Leeds United | First Division | 1 |
| Tommy Lawton | 1936/37 | 13 Feb 1937 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | First Division | 1 |
| Harry Catterick | 1945/46 | 5 Jan 1946 | Preston North End | FA Cup | 1 |
| Jock Dodds | 1946/47 | 2 Nov 1946 | Grimsby Town | First Division | 1 |
| Aubrey Powell | 1948/49 | 21 Aug 1948 | Newcastle United | First Division | 1 |
| Jimmy McIntosh | 1948/49 | 5 Mar 1949 | Blackpool | First Division | 1 |
| Derek Mayers | 1952/53 | 15 Apr 1953 | Bury | Second Division | 2 |
| Bert Llewellyn | 1956/57 | 22 Aug 1956 | Blackpool | First Division | 1 |
| William Haughey | 1956/57 | 19 Apr 1957 | Manchester City | First Division | 1 |
| Jackie Keeley | 1957/58 | 26 Dec 1957 | Bolton Wanderers | First Division | 1 |
| Bobby Collins | 1958/59 | 13 Sep 1958 | Manchester City | First Division | 1 |
| Bobby Laverick | 1958/59 | 18 Feb 1959 | West Bromwich Albion | First Division | 1 |
| Frank Wignall | 1959/60 | 2 Sep 1959 | Burnley | First Division | 1 |
| Keith Webber | 1960/61 | 31 Oct 1960 | Walsall | League Cup | 1 |
| Barrie Rees | 1963/64 | 19 Oct 1963 | West Ham United | First Division | 1 |
| Fred Pickering | 1963/64 | 14 Mar 1964 | Nottingham Forest | First Division | 3 |
| Alan Ball | 1966/67 | 20 Aug 1966 | Fulham | First Division | 1 |
| David Johnson | 1970/71 | 9 Jan 1971 | Burnley | First Division | 1 |
| Mick Lyons | 1970/71 | 20 Mar 1971 | Nottingham Forest | First Division | 1 |
| Ross Jack | 1978/79 | 6 Mar 1979 | Middlesbrough | First Division | 1 |
| Alan Biley | 1981/82 | 29 Aug 1981 | Birmingham City | First Division | 1 |
| Alan Ainscow | 1981/82 | 29 Aug 1981 | Birmingham City | First Division | 1 |
| Rob Wakenshaw | 1983/84 | 5 May 1984 | Manchester United | First Division | 1 |
| Ian Wilson | 1987/88 | 22 Sep 1987 | Rotherham United | League Cup | 1 |
| Tony Cottee | 1988/89 | 27 Aug 1988 | Newcastle United | First Division | 3 |
| Robert Warzycha | 1990/91 | 19 Mar 1991 | Leeds United | Full Members' Cup | 1 |
| David Unsworth | 1991/92 | 25 Apr 1992 | Tottenham Hotspur | First Division | 1 |
| Barry Horne | 1992/93 | 15 Aug 1992 | Sheffield Wednesday | Premier League | 1 |
| Gary Speed | 1996/97 | 17 Aug 1996 | Newcastle United | Premier League | 1 |
| Mickael Madar | 1997/98 | 10 Jan 1998 | Crystal Palace | Premier League | 1 |
| Brian McBride | 2002/03 | 12 Jan 2003 | Tottenham Hotspur | Premier League | 1 |
| James Vaughan | 2004/05 | 10 Apr 2005 | Crystal Palace | Premier League | 1 |
| Andy Johnson | 2006/07 | 19 Aug 2006 | Watford | Premier League | 1 |
| Yakubu | 2007/08 | 1 Sep 2007 | Bolton Wanderers | Premier League | 1 |
| Jô | 2008/09 | 7 Feb 2009 | Bolton Wanderers | Premier League | 2 |
| Gerard Deulofeu | 2013/14 | 28 Aug 2013 | Stevenage | League Cup | 1 |
| Romelu Lukaku | 2013/14 | 21 Sep 2013 | West Ham United | Premier League | 1 |
| Lacina Traore | 2013/14 | 16 Feb 2014 | Swansea City | FA Cup | 1 |
| Samuel Eto'o | 2014/15 | 30 Aug 2014 | Chelsea | Premier League | 1 |
| Ademola Lookman | 2016/17 | 15 Jan 2017 | Manchester City | Premier League | 1 |
| Richarlison | 2018/19 | 11 Aug 2018 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | Premier League | 2 |
| Beto | 2023/24 | 30 Aug 2023 | Doncaster Rovers | League Cup | 1 |
| Ainsley Maitland-Niles | 2026/27 | 6 Sep 2026 | Manchester United | Premier League | 1 |