In
| Player | Team | Date | Fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| Archibald McKenzie | Millwall Athletic | May 1895 | Undisclosed |
| Hugh Robertson | Millwall Athletic | May 1895 | Undisclosed |
| John Henderson | Clyde | May 1895 | Undisclosed |
| Hugh Goldie | St Mirren | 1 May 1895 | Free |
| Albert Flewitt | Lincoln City | 1 May 1895 | £50 |
| George Meiklejohn | Hamilton Academical | 15 July 1895 | Undisclosed |
| John Cameron | Queen's Park | September 1895 | Amateur |
| Alf Schofield | Aintree Church | 18 December 1895 | Free |
| Frank Briggs | Darwen | 7 January 1896 | £50 |
| Davie McDonald | Dundee | 28 February 1896 | Free |
| George Molyneux | Wigan Borough | 20 March 1896 | Free |
| Billy Balmer | Aintree Church | 20 March 1896 | Free |
| Tom Robertson | St Bernard's | 6 April 1896 | 1-month loan |
| Total (initial fees only): | £100 | ||
- John Cameron (Queen's Park) – Transfer completed around 12th September 1895. Signed professional forms on 11th November 1896.
- Alf Schofield (Aintree Church) – Originally on trial.
Out
| Player | Team | Date | Fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| Edward Boylan | Released | 1 May 1895 | |
| Jack Southworth | Released | 1 May 1895 | |
| James McMillan | Released | 1 May 1895 | |
| Fred Geary | Liverpool | 17 May 1895 | £60 |
| John Henderson | Newcastle United | July 1895 | £20 |
| Archibald McKenzie | Sunderland | July 1895 | £15 |
| Hugh Robertson | Burnley | July 1895 | £30 |
| Jack Walker | Leicester Fosse | July 1895 | £10 |
| Fred Collinson | Bury | August 1895 | Undisclosed |
| Charlie Parry | Newtown | December 1895 | Undisclosed |
| Richard Williams | Luton Town | December 1895 | £2 |
| Albert Flewitt | West Bromwich Albion | 15 February 1896 | £40 |
| Total (initial fees only): | £177 | ||
- Edward Boylan (Released) – Eventually joined Rotherham Town on 21st August 1895.
- Jack Southworth (Released) – Never played for another club again.
- James McMillan (Released) – Eventually joined St Bernard's ahead of the 1896/97 season. Unknown if McMillan played for anyone in 1895/96 season after Everton decided not to re-engage him.
- Charlie Parry (Newtown) – Transfer completed around 9th December 1895.
- Richard Williams (Luton Town) – Transfer completed around 16th December 1895. The exact fee Everton received is £2.2.0 (2 pounds and 2 shillings). For calculation purposes, the fee has been rounded down to £2.
| Income | £177 |
| Expenditure | £100 |
| Net Spend | -£77 |