| Rochdale | 4 |
Arthur Richardson 16' Davie Colquhoun 50' Joe Duff 72', 78' | |
| Everton | 2 |
Billy Sumner 8' Cecil Wyles 86' | |
HT: 1-1
Everton win 7-5 on aggregate
Saturday 11 May 1940
1939/40 Football League War Cup second round second leg
Line-Up
- Ted Sagar
- George Jackson
- Norman Greenhalgh
- Cecil Wyles
- Maurice Lindley
- Gordon Watson
- Billy Sumner
- Stan Bentham
- Tommy Lawton
- Alex Stevenson
- Wally Boyes