Everton Women players with the most recorded Women’s FA Cup goals since the club’s adoption in 1995.
NB: The only missing FA Cup goals are all 6 goals in the 6-3 win over Oxford United in December 1995 so the below table is subject to change, hence “recorded” goals.
See also:
- Everton Women’s Highest Ever Goalscorers
- Everton Women’s Highest Ever League Goalscorers
- Everton Women’s Highest Ever Top Flight Goalscorers
- Everton Women’s Highest Ever WSL Goalscorers
- Everton Women’s Highest Ever Goalscorers In The WSL Era
- Everton Women’s Highest Ever League Cup Goalscorers
- Everton Women’s Highest Ever Goalscorers In Europe
Up to and including vs Liverpool, 22nd February 2026.
| Player | Goals |
|---|---|
| Toni Duggan | 15 |
| Jody Handley | 13 |
| Michelle Hinnigan | 12 |
| Fara Williams | 12 |
| Amanda Barr | 10 |
| Natasha Dowie | 7 |
| Michelle Evans | 7 |
| Jill Scott | 7 |
| Louise Thomas | 7 |
| Simone Magill | 6 |
| Olivia Chance | 5 |
| Valerie Gauvin | 5 |
| Kelly McDougall | 5 |
| Nikita Parris | 5 |
| Rachel Unitt | 5 |
| Claudia Walker | 5 |