| Everton | 3 |
Keith Southern 17' Kevin McLeod 40' Leon Osman 80' | |
| Sheffield Wednesday | 1 |
David Knowles 90' (og) | |
HT: 2-0
Monday 1 March 1999
1998/99 FA Youth Cup fifth round replay
Line-Up
- Dean Delany
- John Wright
- David Knowles
- Peter Clarke
- George Pilkington
- Keith Southern
- Leon Osman
- Tony Hibbert
- Kevin McLeod
- Carl Howarth
- Gary Dempsey
Substitutions
HT
Matt McKay
(for Tony Hibbert)