| Manchester United | 2 |
Tommy Spratt 63' Bernard Poole 86' | |
| Everton | 1 |
Andy Penman 40' | |
HT: 0-1
Wednesday 26 November 1958
1958/59 FA Youth Cup second round replay
Line-Up
- Willie Mailey
- Alan Bentham
- Colin Green
- Alan Jarvis
- John Watson
- John Connor
- Andy Penman
- Arthur Peat
- Andy Gearie
- David Boner
- Ken Barton