In
| Player | Team | Date | Fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bobby Simpson | Grangetown Athletic | 2 September 1912 | Free |
| Bill Wareing | Preston North End | 26 October 1912 | £900 |
| Arthur Berry | Liverpool | 11 November 1912 | Amateur |
| James Brannick | Atherton | 22 November 1912 | £75 (+£25 add-ons) |
| Jack Page | Rochdale | 23 November 1912 | £150 |
| Lance Johnston | Blyth Spartans | 30 November 1912 | £100 |
| Sammy Simms | Atherton | 13 December 1912 | £40 |
| Johnny Houston | Linfield | 7 February 1913 | £500 |
| Tommy Stevens | Clyde | 19 February 1913 | £540 |
| Sam Challinor | Witton Albion | 9 April 1913 | £10 (+£40 add-ons) |
| Total (initial fees only): | £2,315 | ||
- Tommy Stevens (Clyde) – Originally on trial.
Out
| Player | Team | Date | Fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clarence Berry | Released | 1 May 1912 | |
| Jack Taylor | Released | 1 May 1912 | |
| Jack Allan | Leeds City | June 1912 | £100 |
| Arthur Berry | Liverpool | 18 June 1912 | Amateur |
| James Meunier | Lincoln City | 19 June 1912 | £50 |
| Rev. Willie Jordan | Wolverhampton Wanderers | June 1912 | Amateur |
| Louis Weller | Chesterfield | July 1912 | £100 |
| Billy Scott | Leeds City | 29 July 1912 | £400 |
| Ernie Pinkney | Barrow | 17 August 1912 | Undisclosed |
| Andy Burton | Reading | 20 September 1912 | £100 |
| Arthur Berry | Oxford City | January 1913 | Amateur |
| Total (initial fees only): | £750 | ||
- Jack Taylor (Released) – Eventually joined South Liverpool in July 1912.
- Jack Allan (Leeds City) – Transfer completed around 10th June 1912. Even though Jack Allan was sold to Leeds City, he remained on Everton's transfer list and received a transfer fee for him when he was sold to Rochdale the following season.
- Rev. Willie Jordan (Wolverhampton Wanderers) – Transfer completed around 29th June 1912. May have joined Southport in February.
- Louis Weller (Chesterfield) – Transfer completed around 22nd July 1912.
| Income | £750 |
| Expenditure | £2,315 |
| Net Spend | +£1,565 |